Who are the patients who are in the intensive care unit with Corona? If you knew where they were infected and why and under what circumstances, then you could protect people at risk better. But the Senate simply does not provide any information, criticizes Gunnar Schupelius
In Berlin, 320 people with corona infection are currently being treated in the intensive care units, 255 of them are so seriously ill that they have to be artificially ventilated (as of November 29).
In the management report of the Health Senate, the current number of corona patients in the intensive care units of the Berlin hospitals is announced every day.
However, there is no information about who is actually there. This information would be important in order to know who the most vulnerable people are. On November 19, we directed detailed questions to Health Senator Dilek Kalayci (SPD), but received no answers. On November 26th we renewed our request – again no answer.
We asked about the average age of the corona intensive care patients, about their body weight, about their additional illnesses. We wanted to know where they live, what nationality they have and above all: why and where did they get infected? What do we know about the viral load they have been exposed to?
Did you get infected even though you followed all the hygiene rules? Did they wear masks? Was the infection inside or outside? Was the infection triggered by a high or low viral load?
If only some of these questions can be clarified, important lessons could be learned. At the moment, measures are often decided on the basis of guesswork. The protection of risk groups has so far played a subordinate role.
► Read all of Gunnar Schupelius’ columns here
If the Health Senator does not answer these questions, then one can only conclude that she cannot answer them. So isn’t the data from intensive care patients evaluated in such a way that conclusions can be drawn from them?
In that case, the Senate will forego the possibility of narrowing down risk groups and risk situations and also giving special protection to those at particular risk.
This protection would be crucial not only for the people in the risk groups, but for all of us. The lockdown is justified with the threat of overloading the intensive care units. Fortunately, anyone who is infected with Corona does not normally end up in the intensive care unit, but only in rare cases and usually under certain conditions that must be researched.
In order to protect people at risk, we need to know these requirements. On top of that, the hard lockdown rules could perhaps be relaxed in many places, social life could get going again and the economy could recover.
But if you don’t even know why someone ends up in the intensive care unit, then you can’t protect them in advance.
So the question again: Why are we not informed who the patients are who are with Corona in the intensive care units?
Is Gunnar Schupelius right? Call: 030/2591 73153, or email: [email protected]